Holding one contract for office software and another for vehicle trackers usually costs more than the two invoices suggest. The extra is staff time: keying the same job twice, reconciling what does not match, and chasing answers across two support lines. For most field service fleets the combined cost of that admin tips the sums towards a single tool. Not every fleet, though, and this article covers both sides.
Adding up the real cost
Licence fees are the visible part. Admin time is the bigger one.
Take a 20-vehicle fleet. The office uses one tool for jobs, scheduling and invoicing, and a tracker platform handles the vans. They rarely talk. A job gets typed into the first, while the journey it relates to sits in the second. A customer asks what time the engineer arrived, and someone opens both screens and matches them by hand.
Here is an illustrative sum; swap in your own numbers. Thirty minutes a day of matching across the team, at £18 an hour fully loaded, is £9 a day or roughly £2,250 over 250 working days. Add the second licence and the second support contract and the gap grows.
Where it leaks
Four places, roughly in order of pain.
Vehicles, drivers and sometimes jobs get entered twice. A new starter or a swapped van means two updates, and the two lists drift apart.
Then the office system says a job ran 9am to 11am while the tracker puts the van elsewhere at 10:15. Which one is right takes a phone call to find out.
Month end is worst. Mileage to jobs, timesheets to journeys, fuel to routes. Nothing a customer pays for comes out of it.
Last, support. A fault appears and each vendor points at the other, leaving you to referee two firms that never designed their products together.
When two is the sensible answer
Sometimes it is. If your office software is good and the team likes it, replacing it brings migration, retraining and disruption, and a working tool has real value.
If different people run the trackers and the office work and never need the same view, the gap may cost very little.
A long contract with exit penalties can also make waiting until renewal cheaper than leaving early.
The test is how often somebody needs a job and its journey side by side. Daily means the split is costing you. Rarely means the case is thin.
What changes with a joined-up tool
The journey behind a job sits beside it on the same map, and arrival times, mileage and time on site come from the vehicle instead of from someone’s typing. With nothing to match, the matching work disappears, and there is a single set of vehicle and driver records plus one number to ring.
AutoM8 is built around that idea. Vehicle tracking and driver scoring are live now. Jobs, scheduling and invoicing are in development, and workflow automation is part of that plan, so ask to see where each stands in a demo before you count on it.
Pricing is agreed on a call, with hardware and fitting covered, so put the quote next to what you pay today.
Do the sum
Add your two licence fees, the second support contract and an honest estimate of matching time, then weigh up that whole total against the invoices alone. If jobs and journeys meet most days, a joined-up tool usually wins on cost and on fewer errors. If they hardly meet, or you are mid-contract on software your team rates, waiting is defensible.
To test it on your own data, book a demo and bring last month’s invoices. Our note on what a free fleet pilot should prove covers how to judge a trial.
Related features